0

I've asked this question:

Is it legitimate to track down a library maintainer who has disappeared?

This is a question about whether something is ethical or not. Naturally, ethics are a matter of interpretation and opinion. This isn't "What's your favorite flavor of ice-cream" opinion-based.

If this question is off-topic, wouldn't any question about ethics also be off-topic? And - is that a good idea?

1 Answer 1

2

First, let us not mix up the terms "opinion-based" with "off-topic". A question about the ethics (of software engineering, of course!) can be perfectly on topic, but still too opinionated to be a good fit for this site.

So I guess what you really wanted to ask is

"wouldn't any question about ethics also be close-worthy as opinion-based"

Indeed, almost any question about ethics is to some degree subjective. But the limit where exactly a question becomes "too opinionated" for this site is a subjective matter as well. In the end, this boils down to the number of community votes a question gets, and our community is full of different opinions about this limit. So maybe if you are lucky, your question in stake will find three people who cast a reopening vote for it. To be honest, I don't intend to, since I agree to the close voters in this specific case - IMHO a "yes" or "no" for this question depends too much on the specific circumstances.

When looking at the ethics tag, I currently see 91 questions, of which 50% are still open. The vast majority of them comes from 2014 and earlier, from the time when the site was named "Programmers" and its focus was a lot wider. Nevertheless there are a few newer questions which are still open, with upvotes and good answers. So at least some ethics questions seem to be acceptable for our community.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .