I was poking around IPS and noticed that at the bottom of their posts you don't find an "add a comment" link. You find a "suggest improvements" link. It does the same thing, but by changing the text it gives a strong hint about the appropriate use of comments.

Just wondering if that idea could work here.

  • 1
    We don't generally have a problem with tons of off-topic comments. We used to, but not anymore. I wouldn't mind running the experiment here as well, but I doubt we'll notice much of a difference.
    – yannis
    Apr 27, 2018 at 7:19

1 Answer 1


Right now, the change from "add a comment" to "suggest improvement" is an experiment on Interpersonal Skills. If the experiment goes well there, it may be expanded to other sites and perhaps the whole network. Also, many other features and functions of the network are being looked at for improvement in order to better explain how to use them or to give new capabilities to help onboard new users or aid power users in doing the things they want to do as part of making the sites on the network more welcoming.

I'm not opposed to turning it on, and if there's strong interest, I can even ask if SESE can become part of this experiment. But I don't see a huge need for it - many comments left are constructive questions about the content of the post they are attached to. The one improvement that I can see is that contents of any back-and-forth in comments can be brought up into the post via edits, but even that appears to happen regularly (if I'm mistaken on that, please let me know).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .