has been closed as unclear and after reading the comments I'm unsure what the community would like me to clarify. The comments seem eager to assume I'm taking a particular position and argue against it. I had hoped the discussion would help improve the question and answers but apparently not enough.
An idea would be to clarify some definitions of terms that some of us seem to be using differently, if only to show how I had intended to use them here. I would be willing to follow up on any suggestions made here to improve it.