In this answer, Thomas Owens says
If 5 users vote, I believe it's majority vote gets the reason. However, if a moderator closes, it's always the moderator's reason.
However, I cast the last close vote on this question and did not observe that behavior - The vote was 2-2 between "asking us to recommend" and "too narrow", and I voted for "too narrow". However, the "asking us to recommend" is the reason that showed up in the close box.
No moderators were involved in the vote.
So, two part question:
- Why was the wrong reason displayed?
- Why not show both?