I asked a question on Programmers, and received 7 upvotes, but got the following comments, if you could spare a look:
And then the question got closed for being
not a real question. But then a user commented on my question, and said this after it being closed:
Yet another highly rated question with a thoughtful, highly-rated answer gets closed for "not being a real question". Three cheers for Stack Exchange.
So I think there really may be a problem here. Could we somehow make the closing system more strict, or make the reopening system more lenient?
I'm not doing this because this is my question, but more because I think this could benefit everyone.