3

This question was closed as a duplicate, but I'm not seeing it. One's asking us to consider issues for a college group project for people who have little to no experience with version control. The alleged duplicate is an experienced version control user wondering whether to switch to something more powerful for one-man non-academic projects. Even though both questions fall into the broad category of "version control," the evaluation criteria are completely different, and therefore the "why" and "how" explanations are going to be different.

It wouldn't surprise me if the question has been asked before, but the linked duplicate isn't it.

  • 2
    would you mind if it gets "re-closed" as not constructive? I was just considering to cast such a vote when it got closed – gnat Apr 20 '12 at 16:18
7

That would be my slip up.

The question had three close votes.

One as a duplicate of the question you linked to, the other two as "not constructive".

I saw the question took a quick look at the duplicate and thought that it was probably a duplicate. However, looking at it now I see that it's not really.

However, I would have closed as not constructive, so I'm going to go ahead and and reopen and reclose with the correct close reason.

  • It still felt like there was a good question in there somewhere. Would an edit along the lines of "what factors are most consequential in this situation" make it constructive? – Karl Bielefeldt Apr 20 '12 at 17:40
  • @KarlBielefeldt "most sequential" feels quite slippery. "How do I tell which VCS <insert the purpose here>?" - probably less so – gnat Apr 20 '12 at 18:43
3

I agree with you.

They do seem like altogether different questions to me, however the original question still seems terribly Not Constructive. It is basically inviting a bunch of answers with peoples opinions on their favorite source control with high general metrics:

easy to use (ie this should be a tool they can use rather than spend a lot of time fighting it)

Easy to install and maintain for the person who does this.

still be relevant for subsequent professional work once they graduate

These are desirable traits in a good laptop let alone source control software.

The question should still be closed in my opinion but I just feel the reason listed is wrong.

EDIT: ChrisF posted his response before me, this answer is now defunct!

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .