One thing that keeps coming up is the number of questions that are closed solely by moderator action on this site. We've already been over some of the issues, but I'm going to take this opportunity to write up a guide here on meta blatantly rip off a guide to closing from Ninefingers' post on Cryptography meta.


Adapted from Cryptography meta, originally posted by Ninefingers

Rationale: why do we close questions?

There are really two ways to do moderation. If you've been on any of the .moderated newsgroups you'll be well aware that to get a post on there, it needs to undergo a review process first and be accepted. The aim is to keep problem discussions from arising.

SE is slightly different - it works the other way. Anyone can ask a question on SE and closing a question is the equivalent of putting that question back into review/improve mode. It's a feedback mechanism designed to react to problem cases only, so the usual business of asking and answering good questions can just... happen.

Why do we close a question?

The philosophy of SE is that each site handles questions on problems you face or things you are trying to understand. The don't ask section of the FAQ gives you a good overview of things that don't work - to summarise:

  • Some questions invite arguments or extended debate that suck up time when members could be helping other people.
  • Some questions are too broad, too narrow or have other content problems.
  • Some questions belong elsewhere.

These have been worked out over time and with a lot of experience from Stack Overflow and are, broadly speaking true. Sometimes, exceptions are made - it is always a case-by-case thing.

Is closing like deletion?

No, and this is an important distinction, deletion is a different concept on SE. Closed questions are put "into improve mode" if you like, and are still visible for anyone to improve. That's the idea. Deleted questions are different - they have a red background and are invisible to all but high reputation users. So deletion is different and solves a slightly different problem.

What are the requirements for closing a question?

If you have 3000 reputation on the site you can vote to close any question for the reasons above. More on that in a moment.

If you do not have this level of reputation, you will find that under the flag menu, you have an option "this question does not belong here". That will raise a flag for users who can vote to close.

Why can anyone vote to close/reopen?

Firstly, anyone can vote to close or reopen (or flag as such) because it is your site. This is really important - it's about expressing what you feel works and doesn't.

How are moderators different?

Moderator close votes complete the required vote count immediately, no matter how many people have voted. This applies for both close/reopen votes.

Initially, as the reputation requirement rules out many users, you will see moderators doing most of the closing to guide the site and look after the content. As you gain in reputation, you get to join in.

Ok, so how does it work?

Example close button

Ok, the important piece. Voting to close works like this:

  • Underneath the question, there will be a close link. When you click on this, you will be presented with a list of options from which you can pick a close reason most appropriate to the situation.

Close vote reasons dialog

  • If other people have voted, you will see red numbers against the reason they chose.

Other votes

  • The exact duplicate page takes you to a page that allows you to specify a question to close as an exact duplicate against.
  • The "off topic" page will present you with five options - three standard reasons why a post is off topic, one to specify your own custom reason and one to migrate the question to a different site. Users can migrate question here and to [so]. Moderators can send questions elsewhere, so feel free to flag if you have a target in mind.
  • The other options are straight out closes.
  • Once you pick your option and click "close", your vote is registered.
  • If five people agree that the question needs closing, the question will be closed, even if they don't agree on the reason. You've seen the effect of these before.
  • The majority vote is chosen as the published close reason. This is a simple 3/2 split. In the case of a 2/2/1 split the the last voted reason wins.
  • Your name, and the name of other closers, will appear on the bottom of the question.

Close banner

How does vote to re-open work?

A closed question has a "reopen" link underneath it. If you click this, a dialog box will ask you if you are sure - click yes and your vote will be registered to re-open the question.

Below, you can see an example of the re-open link with two votes registered for re-opening (out of five).

Re-open link

What happens if I make a mistake?

Don't worry! Unless five people agree, or a moderator agrees, the question won't be closed.
Furthermore, you have the possibility to retract your close vote. This possibility is provided if you try to cast a second close vote on a question. After retracting your vote, you can not cast it again, so you can't use vote retraction to change the close reason.

I've seen a closed question and I disagree. What can I do?

Well, one option is to use your re-open vote! You can also always raise a discussion here on meta to seek clarification on why a question is closed and hopefully either a resolution will be reached, or you will get an explanation for the closure.

My name appears on the bottom - isn't this going to cause problems with other users?

Actually, surprisingly few closed questions generate any response at all.

However, if you experience difficulties as a result of closing a question, you can and should contact a moderator via the flag mechanism (which is anonymous). We can then take any necessary action.

How do I find questions I might need to close? What about re-opens?

Actually there are two tools for this.

  • Review. Here, there are a number of options for seeing things that might need say editing. One of these is a tab for all questions with close votes. You are then free to look at the question and decide if you agree.
  • Tools. Commonly referred to as the "10k tools", this page let's you see even more information - certain anonymous flags, re-open votes, delete votes etc. The important one for this is the re-open page. Here, you can see questions that might have been closed incorrectly.
  • I believe 5 votes are required to close a question. If 2 ppl close as it off-topic, 2 as not-constructive, 1 as not a real question. Will that still close the question?
    – Noname
    Feb 6 '12 at 20:32
  • 3
    @Dave- yes. 5 votes in total close. The majority vote is the published close reason. A simple 3/2 for all except migration, which requires 4/1. In the case of a 2/2/1 split the the last voted reason wins.
    – ChrisF Mod
    Feb 6 '12 at 21:06
  • @ChrisF I read the original at Crypto yesterday and I was thinking of stealing it as well... :)
    – yannis
    Feb 6 '12 at 22:55
  • @YannisRizos - it's going round the network...
    – ChrisF Mod
    Feb 6 '12 at 22:56

Adapted from meta.wordpress.stackexchange.

Recommended Reading


  • I Move to Close This Question

    How and why closing was introduced on Stack Overflow in 2008.

    It’s important to note here that closing a question is a step on the road to deletion. Closing is effectively “nominate to delete”, as a question that can’t be answered is no longer truly “alive”. That said, some closed questions should be kept around. For example, duplicate questions that have totally different wording are sometimes useful. With the duplicates, people can find either variation with search terms and link through to the original.

  • The Wikipedia of Long Tail Programming Questions

    About duplicates.

    Don’t answer questions that have already been answered elsewhere. Yeah, you might earn a couple of points of reputation, but, because you are duplicating content, you are actually making the internet worse. Why? Because that answer might be true today, but as technology changes, it might not be true tomorrow.

  • The Stack Overflow Question Lifecycle

    How and when questions are closed or deleted.

  • Real Questions Have Answers, Gorilla vs. Shark and Q&A is Hard, Let’s Go Shopping!

    About the not constructive close reason.

Meta Stack Overflow

My own summary after a long reading session

Closing is not deleting. A closed question is still visible, it can be improved and reopened. It doesn’t affect the accept rate but prevents potentially useless answers. Help us to stay on focus, use your close votes.

As a moderator (on WordPress Stack Exchange) I don’t like to act unilaterally. Your close votes are helping me and the other moderators to decide and we don’t feel so bad if we close a question. :)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .