4 replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
source | link

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questionshttps://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

3 Fixup of bad MSO links to MSE links migration
source | link

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

How to ask and answer homework questions?http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

How to ask and answer homework questions?

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

2 Migration of MSO links to MSE links
source | link

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questionsHow to ask and answer homework questions?

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/10811/how-to-ask-and-answer-homework-questions

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

This may or may not have been asked on our meta site before but it was certainly a well discussed issue at Meta StackOverflow.

How to ask and answer homework questions?

As far as I know, this discussion here applies equally as well to homework questions about design, algorithms, and software development in general. I personally agree with the highest voted answer there.

So we have established that if a student falls in the acceptable guidelines for asking a homework question that it is okay, now we ask ourselves if this policy towards homework questions is ethical.

In my opinion it is ethical.

If people are simply providing the answer with no context then perhaps the student might copy the answer and get a good grade now, but how does this prepare the student for future assignments and exams? This doesn't help the student in the long term because they haven't learned anything and we will not always be there to hold there hand. Eventually they must stand on their own two feet or they will be unsuccessful in life and in their career.

If an answer is good and provides context however then we as a community have a real opportunity to tutor the student and teach them the concepts that will help them do well in school, life and their careers.

Grades are a temporary thing, knowledge once gained is kept forever.

1
source | link